Ayan Mukerji made a formal announcement of Brahmastra soon after the success of Ranbir Kapoor's Yeh Jawaani Hai Deewani (2013). I was in my last year of engineering then, and now the project is finally released in 2022. Most of the delayed Bollywood projects have bad records to their names, except for Mughal-e-Azam (1960) and Pakeezah (1972), so of course you can't expect Brahmastra to hit that level. Ayan's dream project somewhere dies in between these two verdicts. It is neither too bad like those unsuccessful films nor too good like Mughal-e-Azam and Pakeezah. Ayan's dream is visually pleasant just like you enjoy in your dreams, but the writing and storytelling are something that you wouldn't even dream of for a decade old film. It seems that Ayan was stuck in 2013 while writing this film, and he didn't know that Bollywood had come a long way in 2022.Brahmastra is a long narrative divided into three parts (at least that's what Ayan has in mind), and the first part is mainly about Shiva (Ranbir Kapoor). It's about Shiva knowing about his powers, the secrets of Brahmastra, his exploration with himself, aka Agni-Astra, and the love of his life, Isha (Alia Bhatt). Amitabh Bachchan is a sort of Guru (maybe people don't want to imagine him in any other role for such big films) as well as a Prabhastra, who helps Shiva to unleash his powers. The Brahmansh team is guarding three pieces of Brahmastra, the God of all Astras, from Junoon (Mouni Roy). She wants to awaken her Guru, Dev (unknown yet, or let's keep it a secret for now). The film starts with a much-hyped cameo (Shah Rukh Khan), which ultimately goes on to disappoint you with its chapri dialogues. The past connection is there and it is as predictable as it could have been, but it stretches itself long enough to give a declaration about Brahmastra: Part Two.
Brahmastra's writing is all about cliches. The romance, the good vs. evil face off, the past connection, the guru and shishya pattern, and the positive ending. Don't tell me you haven't seen it before, and in such a manner. The expected flaws are there to raise many questions in your mind, but there are some basic mistakes which cannot be overlooked. How can people with the powers of Astras be killed with guns? I mean, even the villains use guns to defeat the good guys, who have tremendous powers. They have powers but don't use them because they have to use guns first. Someone with super jumping abilities must first run (for what? ), then jump.The romance between Shiva and Alia starts off as a slumber-bound flirt and stays flat throughout, yet is used as the main event of the storyline. In one of the scenes, Shiva and Isha are going to some party around midnight of Diwali, but they don't walk or just run, but they climb and literally sort of fly just to reach a small house. And where was that so-called 'todu party', by the way? If you see the past connection part, you don't even need further details to predict who it was actually and how Shiva is connected to them. You don't get any big surprises as promised, but maybe there is an outside chance that we may get them in the next parts (if they are made soon). Ayan should have finished this film with such a storyline before 2015 (the beginning of the Bahubali era), and then it might have looked better. It's definitely outdated and flawed for 2022. I don't know why it took so long because such stories can be written every day after a good sleep.Talking about performances, Brahmastra isn't a front-loaded film. Ranbir Kapoor is out of soft boy roles and has done a decent job with this mixed and messy character. The Chapri accent just didn't look good on him, not even for a moment. Alia Bhatt has pulled her graph down after giving good performances in Gangubai Kathiawadi and Darlings. Brahmastra is not even half of what she has done in those two previous films this year. Amitabh Bachchan hardly makes any impact with a sober and predictable role, but his accent and persona suit the respected image. Nagarjuna has about a 5 to 6-minute role with a powerful presence. The surprise package is Mouni Roy, who has done very well as the antagonist. She looks scary and devious. She has a beautiful face too, and she is powerful enough to stand against Shiva and the Brahmansh members. Shah Rukh Khan plays a scientist-cum-one of the astras (as reported by many websites already) but has got cheap dialogues to deliver.Pritam barely gives any bad albums, so he doesn't go wrong with Brahmastra either. Deva Deva and Kesariya are watchful songs with engaging visuals, whereas Dance Ka Bhoot passes the screentime somehow. Simon Franglen's background score is rooted in Indian culture and tones, which was unexpected from him. But what an incredible impact it had in those battle scenes! Literally goosebumps! The cinematography and editing could have been better, and the dialogues needed a little bit of modern polishing. Watch out for the VFX. Brahmastra presents the best visual spectacle of Indian cinema, with 3D effects adding more joy to the viewing experience.Ayan Mukerji has come out of coming-of-age dramas and entered the mysterious world of ancient astras. He seemed confused about what to pick and carry and what to drop. Brahmastra: Part One could have been a fantastic film with a good script, but Ayan just couldn't get the basics right. His conviction about visualisation fits the bill, but the idea of the same isn't that big. It's on the same level as Shankar's 2 Point 0 – great VFX but a mediocre storyline. If someone like Shankar can go wrong after making films like Indian, Anniyan and Endhiran, then Ayan was too small for it already. Nonetheless, Brahmastra is watchable for its big-screen value that introduces you to VFX-led grandeur, though it lacks both a storyline and storytelling, which could have taken it to the next level. The young guy has done more than his age, though.